[arg_discuss] whitepaper:wiki, next version

[Brian Clark]

>Well, it appears that the substance of my last two posts were lost in

>translation. Let's try this again...


Not to everyone, Brooke.

As an outside observer, Adam: it appears to me that people had their
feelings hurt rather broadly in the community for a broad variety of
reasons. I took Brooke's strong tone not as an attack against you, but an
attack against dismissing that conversation out-of-hand as having "very
little" constructive about it. I agreed personally which much of that
criticism: that's what peer review is supposed to be at its heart. 


B.