[LSC] File Format Restrictions for Official Parts

[William Howard]

3 degree - 91 parts, 1241 warped quads
2 degree - 112 parts, 1836 warped quads
1 degree - 144 parts, 5002 warped quads

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Orion Pobursky" <orion at ldraw.org>
To: "LDraw Standards Committee" <lsc at ldraw.org>
Sent: Friday, November 23, 2007 6:02 AM
Subject: Re: [LSC] File Format Restrictions for Official Parts



> Travis Cobbs wrote:

>> On Nov 22, 2007 1:17 PM, Michael Heidemann <mikeheide at web.de> wrote:

>>

>>>  I just walked through the revised version. Here my remarks:

>>>

>>> *Co-planar Tolerance*

>>> Do we have already agreed to the angle value of 1? Or can it be more 

>>> like

>>> 2 or 3?

>>>

>>

>> I don't think we really discussed this.  I'm open on the value.  I wonder

>> how hard it would be to run Philo's tool on all existing official parts 

>> with

>> varying thresholds to see what a "reasonable" value would be.  For 

>> example,

>> if 1 gives us 200 "bad" parts, 2 gives us 10, and 3 gives us 8, I'd 

>> probably

>> prefer 2.

>

> I modified Philo program to do this.  Attached is the output for 1, 2, and 

> 3

>

> -Orion

>

> -- 

> We don't stop playing because we grow old;

> we grow old because we stop playing

> -George Bernard Shaw

>



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



> 193a.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 193b.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 2046.dat, 70 warped quad(s) detected

> 2418a.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2418b.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2545.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 2546.dat, 74 warped quad(s) detected

> 2546p01.dat, 90 warped quad(s) detected

> 2556.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 2561.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 2587.dat, 42 warped quad(s) detected

> 2598.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2638.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2741.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 2875.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2917.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2951.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2999.dat, 14 warped quad(s) detected

> 30027.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 30034.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 30082.dat, 12 warped quad(s) detected

> 30117.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 30139.dat, 32 warped quad(s) detected

> 30149.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 30173.dat, 56 warped quad(s) detected

> 30195.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 30303.dat, 36 warped quad(s) detected

> 30361.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 30378.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 30378ps1.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 30378ps2.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 30407.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 32136.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 32165.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 32166.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 32172.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 32189.dat, 3 warped quad(s) detected

> 32535.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3297ps1.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3298p21.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3298p54.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 3470.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 3471.dat, 40 warped quad(s) detected

> 3626bps8.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 3705c01.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 3730.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 3737c01.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 3833.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 3834.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 3844.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 3901.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 4006.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 4080.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4289.dat, 14 warped quad(s) detected

> 4491a.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4491b.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4493.dat, 49 warped quad(s) detected

> 4494.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 4495.dat, 10 warped quad(s) detected

> 4515p03.dat, 5 warped quad(s) detected

> 4523.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 4596.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4617.dat, 12 warped quad(s) detected

> 4624.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 4629.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4698.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 4716b.dat, 42 warped quad(s) detected

> 4737.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 522.dat, 27 warped quad(s) detected

> 6084.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 6085.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 6118.dat, 110 warped quad(s) detected

> 6131.dat, 42 warped quad(s) detected

> 6152.dat, 3 warped quad(s) detected

> 6153.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 6222.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 6233.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 6589.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 6637b.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 6637c.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 68.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 70.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 71015.dat, 96 warped quad(s) detected

> 750.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 752.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 773.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 792.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 794.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 870.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 90.dat, 12 warped quad(s) detected

> 971ps5.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

>



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



> 111.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 193a.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 193b.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 2046.dat, 98 warped quad(s) detected

> 2418a.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2418b.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2545.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 2546.dat, 80 warped quad(s) detected

> 2546p01.dat, 96 warped quad(s) detected

> 2556.dat, 26 warped quad(s) detected

> 2561.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 2587.dat, 48 warped quad(s) detected

> 2598.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 2638.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2682.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2741.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 2875.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2917.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2951.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2983.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2999.dat, 14 warped quad(s) detected

> 30027.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 30034.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 30082.dat, 12 warped quad(s) detected

> 30117.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 30139.dat, 32 warped quad(s) detected

> 30149.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 30173.dat, 56 warped quad(s) detected

> 30195.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 30213.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 30303.dat, 40 warped quad(s) detected

> 30361.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 30378.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 30378ps1.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 30378ps2.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 30407.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3183.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 32136.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 32165.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 32166.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 32172.dat, 7 warped quad(s) detected

> 32173.dat, 3 warped quad(s) detected

> 32189.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 32191.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 32535.dat, 3 warped quad(s) detected

> 3297ps1.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3298p21.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3298p54.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 3470.dat, 32 warped quad(s) detected

> 3471.dat, 52 warped quad(s) detected

> 3491.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 3626bps8.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 3650a.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 3705c01.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 3730.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 3737c01.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 378.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3833.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 3834.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 3844.dat, 14 warped quad(s) detected

> 3896.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 3901.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4006.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 4080.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4289.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 4447.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4491a.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4491b.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4493.dat, 79 warped quad(s) detected

> 4494.dat, 62 warped quad(s) detected

> 4495.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 4515p03.dat, 10 warped quad(s) detected

> 4523.dat, 12 warped quad(s) detected

> 4524.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4596.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4617.dat, 18 warped quad(s) detected

> 4624.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 4629.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4698.dat, 68 warped quad(s) detected

> 4716b.dat, 42 warped quad(s) detected

> 4737.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 522.dat, 34 warped quad(s) detected

> 577.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 6084.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 6085.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 6118.dat, 110 warped quad(s) detected

> 6127.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 6131.dat, 58 warped quad(s) detected

> 6152.dat, 3 warped quad(s) detected

> 6153.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 6157.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 6159.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 6222.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 6233.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 6252.dat, 48 warped quad(s) detected

> 635.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 636.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 6589.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 6637b.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 6637c.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 68.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 70.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 71015.dat, 102 warped quad(s) detected

> 731.dat, 104 warped quad(s) detected

> 750.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 752.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 773.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 792.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 794.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 870.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 90.dat, 12 warped quad(s) detected

> 971ps5.dat, 3 warped quad(s) detected

>



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



> 108.dat, 640 warped quad(s) detected

> 110.dat, 640 warped quad(s) detected

> 111.dat, 7 warped quad(s) detected

> 112.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 193a.dat, 64 warped quad(s) detected

> 193b.dat, 64 warped quad(s) detected

> 2046.dat, 100 warped quad(s) detected

> 2418a.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2418b.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2464.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2488.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 2526.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2545.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 2546.dat, 82 warped quad(s) detected

> 2546p01.dat, 100 warped quad(s) detected

> 2556.dat, 80 warped quad(s) detected

> 2561.dat, 12 warped quad(s) detected

> 2587.dat, 52 warped quad(s) detected

> 2598.dat, 12 warped quad(s) detected

> 2638.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2682.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2713.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2741.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 2743.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2773.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2875.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2917.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2918.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2951.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 2983.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 2999.dat, 14 warped quad(s) detected

> 30027.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 30034.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 30082.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 30117.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 30139.dat, 64 warped quad(s) detected

> 30149.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 30173.dat, 56 warped quad(s) detected

> 30195.dat, 14 warped quad(s) detected

> 30213.dat, 12 warped quad(s) detected

> 30303.dat, 40 warped quad(s) detected

> 30361.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 30378.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 30378ps1.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 30378ps2.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 30407.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3127.dat, 80 warped quad(s) detected

> 3183.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 32039.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 32054.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 32068.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 32136.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 32165.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 32166.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 32172.dat, 9 warped quad(s) detected

> 32173.dat, 10 warped quad(s) detected

> 32184.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 32189.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 32191.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 32291.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 32310.dat, 5 warped quad(s) detected

> 32535.dat, 7 warped quad(s) detected

> 3297ps1.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3298p21.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3298p54.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 3298p61.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 3470.dat, 40 warped quad(s) detected

> 3471.dat, 68 warped quad(s) detected

> 3491.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 3626bp3j.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3626bp7a.dat, 10 warped quad(s) detected

> 3626bps8.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 3626bpsc.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 3650a.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 3705c01.dat, 96 warped quad(s) detected

> 3730.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 3737c01.dat, 96 warped quad(s) detected

> 378.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 3833.dat, 32 warped quad(s) detected

> 3834.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 3844.dat, 18 warped quad(s) detected

> 3896.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 3901.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 4006.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 4080.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4273.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 4289.dat, 18 warped quad(s) detected

> 44.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 4447.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4491a.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4491b.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4493.dat, 114 warped quad(s) detected

> 4494.dat, 107 warped quad(s) detected

> 4495.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 4515p03.dat, 25 warped quad(s) detected

> 4523.dat, 16 warped quad(s) detected

> 4524.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4596.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4617.dat, 30 warped quad(s) detected

> 4624.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 4629.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 4698.dat, 72 warped quad(s) detected

> 4716b.dat, 42 warped quad(s) detected

> 4737.dat, 10 warped quad(s) detected

> 476.dat, 20 warped quad(s) detected

> 517.dat, 448 warped quad(s) detected

> 522.dat, 36 warped quad(s) detected

> 551.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 577.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 6084.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 6085.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 6118.dat, 150 warped quad(s) detected

> 6127.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 6131.dat, 80 warped quad(s) detected

> 6152.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 6153.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 6157.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 6159.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 6222.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 6233.dat, 32 warped quad(s) detected

> 6252.dat, 96 warped quad(s) detected

> 635.dat, 48 warped quad(s) detected

> 636.dat, 48 warped quad(s) detected

> 6536.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 6589.dat, 24 warped quad(s) detected

> 6637b.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 6637c.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 6641.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 68.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 70.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 70501b.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 71015.dat, 142 warped quad(s) detected

> 731.dat, 368 warped quad(s) detected

> 750.dat, 9 warped quad(s) detected

> 752.dat, 9 warped quad(s) detected

> 760.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 773.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

> 792.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 794.dat, 4 warped quad(s) detected

> 870.dat, 8 warped quad(s) detected

> 90.dat, 20 warped quad(s) detected

> 971pa2.dat, 1 warped quad(s) detected

> 971phb.dat, 2 warped quad(s) detected

> 971ps5.dat, 6 warped quad(s) detected

>



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



> _______________________________________________

> LSC mailing list

> LSC at ldraw.org

> http://five.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/lsc

>